Review - Dreamwalker by C. S. Friedman

Dreamwalker by C.S. Friedman

My rating: 4 of 5 stars



This was markedly better than some reviews made it out to be. It does help if you start it with the mentality that it's a YA-level book; adults are not the intended audience but are not excluded from enjoying it. It's no where near as dark as Friedman's other fantasy works, although it's certainly not a "light" story and has the potential to grow into something more characteristic of her earlier works.

It does have the "which boy do I like!?!" triangle of YA novels (although, two great choices... can't really argue against either one at this point and I like the reality of lacking an obvious option). My biggest qualm was the obviousness/repetitiveness of parts of the world-building and that some of the references in the plot (Kindles, iPhones, Twilight, etc.) are going to be dated in a very short time. Again though, this reflects the YA nature of the novel; it's just not geared for readers like me who like lasting subtlety and suspension of disbelief.

However, the world-building set up has an interesting premise. There is lots more Friedman can do with this universe. This book lays the groundwork well and I would certainly pick up the next couple of books to find out more. The lead characters are also likeable, their emotions are relatable, their situation compelling. This was a fast read and the pace was steady throughout.

If you like YA fantasy done well, this is your book. If you've sworn off YA entirely, I would still encourage trying it out, although I wouldn't insist; Friedman has lots of amazing adult fantasy and science fiction stories that are ripe for re-reads. I enjoyed this one as a YA read and look forward to the next book.

Review - Thief's Magic by Trudi Canavan (Millenium Rule #1)

Thief's Magic by Trudi Canavan

My rating: 4 of 5 stars



I wavered between 3 and 5 stars with this book, almost always at different sections. It's told from the perspective of two protagonists, Tyen and Rielle, who are on different worlds with the same magic system basis. Canavan is attempting something more epic than her previous works and with some pretty solid success. While both of the lead characters' stories were complete for a "first in a series" book, Canavan lays down some tantalizing hints of the larger mechanics and mythology of this universe.

Tyen's story, which kicks off the book, was attention grabbing but flagged for me through the middle of the book. I had to keep reminding myself that Canavan is not a "more than meets the eye" kind of writer; there are no sudden reversals or "why didn't I see that?!" moments. The story relies heavily on your sympathy with the protagonists, which was somewhat weak for me in Tyen's sections. Rielle, on the other hand, was interesting throughout (the 5 star sections were exclusively hers). I did enjoy the secondary characters in both storylines; Canavan's cast is full of individuals, not Examples of a Type. The contrast amongst the priests of Rielle's world were particularly good.

Definitely looking forward to the follow ups. Recommended for Canavan's fans and readers looking for a new, solid epic fantasy series.

Review - Valour and Vanity (Glamourist #4)

Valour and Vanity by Mary Robinette Kowal

My rating: 5 of 5 stars



Kowal's (by now characteristic) thorough research and attention to detail shines again to create a fascinating and immersive story. In particular, I loved the insights into different strata of life in this novel, the very poor, the working class, the well-off, the nuns, etc. They all felt like people, never caricatures, which takes careful work. As a fantasy fan, I also liked the furthering of glamour techniques and the Vincents' skills as a "development of magic" angle. I'm very curious to see where that goes in the final novel!

My only qualm with this book was the beginning. It's a heist novel and the end comeuppance is tight and excellent and clever, everything I could have asked for. (Kowal writes a little in the afterword about how the final action scene needed to be written and I'm awed at the flawless execution.) But the early groundwork felt a little too slow to develop, as Jane's trusting nature obscures the underlying plot. I debated whether this was my lack of insight or the way it was written and I suspect it's a little of both. Jane's point of view is written so engrossingly that it was difficult for me to step outside it and consider other angles. All-in-all, it's a characteristic of the character-based story and not a flaw; definitely an experience that makes me want to re-read to see what I get out of it a second time.

The highlight of this book, as always, were the characters of Jane & Vincent. I greatly enjoyed my time in their company, particularly as their situation strained & strengthened their relationship. Kowal deftly handles their reactions to events past and present, never glossing over the strain that these events can place on even the most loving relationships.

This is the 4th book of a projected 5 book series and is still highly recommended for fantasy fans, regency readers, and now fans of heist novels!

Review - The Way of Kings (Revisited) by Brandon Sanderson

The Way of Kings by Brandon Sanderson

My rating: 4 of 5 stars



This was my second read of this novel (see my first review) and occurred both before, during, and after I read its sequel, Words of Radiance. It holds up well after 3 years and, frankly, was a better read after I finished #2. Some plot and thematic elements become more apparent and reading them back to back lets one eliminate the initial bump of in-world terminology.

I found Kaladin a much more tolerable lead character this time. Since the book's initial publication, when I first read it, I've learned much more about depression and its inescapable presence. Kaladin reads as an authentic depressed character now that I've put that together. Dalinar again annoyed me a bit, although Adolin was also more interesting after reading book 2. Nonetheless, Jasnah & Shallan are still my favorite storyline and I greatly enjoyed the secondary cast of characters.

Definitely still recommended for epic fantasy fans. At only 2 books in, this world is already rich and deep enough to get more out of the first installment.

Review - The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms by N. K. Jemisin

The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms by N.K. Jemisin

My rating: 3 of 5 stars



I wavered between 3 and 4 stars for this. While it was a solid read, I probably won't pick it up again, although I will read the sequel.

Part of my issue with the book was my expectations, as usual. When your main character is thrust into a scheming, ends-justifies-the-means ruling family, I was set up to read some vicious politicking and clever court intrigue. Instead, this novel is more a story about the enslaved gods' rise to freedom via Yeine's personal beliefs. Also a good story but I kept expecting a double cross or redemption somewhere that never happened.

But. The worldbuilding was excellent. I want to know more, more, more about what happens to this world. And the not-overdone commentary on slavery, lack of gender issues, and especially Jemisin's show-not-tell story on how others expectations shape us were all thought provoking. The secondary characters were a bit two dimensional but Yeine, Nahadoth, Sieh, and Enefa were all interesting.

Worth a read through for fantasy fans looking for something a little different, if you can tolerate the odd moment of extreme violence. I'm looking forward to the next installment.

Review - Wintersmith by Terry Pratchett

Wintersmith by Terry Pratchett

My rating: 4 of 5 stars



This was my first ever Terry Pratchett book and if they're all like this, I could be spending many hours with this author in the near future.

The book never takes itself too seriously, which means the reader really can't either. But don't let that belie the solid craft and excellent story at work here. Pratchett has fun at the expense of many a trope or fantasy element and consistently underscores the point of Story: what we learn about ourselves as a result. I have an engineer's brain that likes to find and solve problems, so it's rare for me to say that there's nothing wrong with a book. It was so nice to sit back and just enjoy a story without having to say "except for this one thing...".

This may be a little dense for those not accustomed to fantasy/fairy tales/mythology but if you have even a passing familiarity with any one of those, I imagine you would find something fun here. Not an earth shattering, mind bending read but very enjoyable. I'll definitely be picking up more Discworld books in the future.

Review - Except the Queen by Jane Yolen and Midori Snyder

Except the Queen by Jane Yolen & Midori Snyder

My rating: 3 of 5 stars



I read this for my book club and hoped that the discussion would let me decide if I liked it or not. Alas, this was not to be.

There's nothing really wrong with this book and I suspect I was simply not the intended audience (not a huge follower of fae/fairy tales, so many of the plot elements left me puzzled). I just never felt particularly connected to the characters. Or the plot. Or the world.

It was an easy enough read and I enjoyed the gentle humor inherent in two people finding their way in an unfamiliar culture.

I've read books by Yolen before and enjoyed them and have several of Snyder's on my "to read" list. This book didn't made me move Snyder's work ahead or behind where it is now.

Recommended to those interested in both fairy tales and urban fantasy.

Review - Without a Summer by Mary Robinette Kowal

Without a Summer by Mary Robinette Kowal
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

The very best comment I can make about this book is that Kowal perfectly interweaves Regency sensibilities and modern thought processes without ever making one intrude on the other. Everything I know about the Regency period in Britain meshes perfectly with what she has written but no language or cultural detail slows or obscures the plot. Having followed the author's blog commentary, I know that she has paid particular attention to getting period details of dress, etiquette, vocabulary, and culture correct and it pays of in an immersive reading experience.

Most importantly, it's a fun novel. Equal parts period fiction, fantasy, & mystery, Kowal demonstrates that a well told story is not confined to one genre. The character arcs of protagonist Jane, her husband Vincent, and her sister Melody show realistic growth as each learns about traits that are holding them back. Anyone who enjoys period details will love this novel, which describes dress and social etiquette by making it essential to an understanding of the social tensions within the plot.

This novel can be read on its own but I highly recommend the two previous novels. Watching Kowal develop as a novelist is a truly wonderful journey and I look forward to the concluding volume of this series with great anticipation.

View all my reviews

Review - Glamour in Glass by Mary Robinette Kowal

Glamour in Glass by Mary Robinette Kowal
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The second in a series, Glamour in Glass is an improvement over the first installment. This entry feels more "correct" for the Regency/Napoleonic period, possibly due to the author's focus on using period language. This book has a tighter focus in characters as well; however, the newer characters are still interesting.

I enjoyed the further glimpses into Vincent's past as well as the inclusion of historical background. The cultural juxtaposition that Kowal uses also added tension and interest to the plot. The "mystery" is pretty obvious from an experienced reader's perspective but credible as being confusing to Jane. This is, after all, not a mystery novel, so that is hardly a mark against it.

This is still an easy read, although with the inclusion of the tensions on the continent, Vincent's torture, and Jane's miscarriage it is not as light as the first. Recommended for those who have read the first book; your continued interest will be rewarded. This is actually one series where you could start with book #2 and not be terribly lost.

Review - Shades of Milk and Honey by Mary Robinette Kowal

Shades of Milk and Honey by Mary Robinette Kowal
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

This book shows tremendous promise from a new novelist. I am a little disappointed that I didn't like this better after hearing overwhelmingly good reviews from trusted sources. A Regency/Napoleonic historical fantasy novel, it is drawing the inevitable comparisons to Jane Austen's works. The author herself has stated that Austen was her chief literary inspiration.

This is unfortunate, as it tends to make the new story weaker in comparison than it would be alone. While not an Austen expert or fangirl by any means, I do enjoy the witty by-play and social commentary she used to such pointed effect. Kowal's novel seems simpler somehow for not having these subtleties. She does handle the stock characters well- Jane is the eldest daughter, not pretty but with other skills, past marriageable age; Melody is the beauty and hope of the family but naive and spoiled; Mrs. Ellsworth is the neurotic mother concerned only with her own health and marrying off her daughters; and Mr. Ellsworth is the responsible but doting father.

Even the secondary characters have personality, better than some experienced novelists write. There is real tension between Jane and Mr. Dunkirk, affection between Jane and Miss Dunkirk, and mystery about Mr. Vincent. I felt that the plot line kept me guessing about Jane and Melody's matches until most of the way through the book, rather than giving it away early as so many regency novels do. (view spoiler)[Livingston's character was apparent from the beginning but the others had their elements of uncertainty. I also think the "fall" of Mr. Dunkirk in Jane's estimation was nicely done. Jane resolves the question with her own judgement, rather than having a "marry him because he's the hero" type resolution. (hide spoiler)]

The novel has a solid structure and does show potential for growth. Kowal does a tremendous job using magic ("glamour") as a part of everyday existence. There are no bang-up magic duels here, just a new tool in the gentry's arsenal. Jane is a likeable protagonist and the conflict between the sisters is more apparent than is represented in other Regency works. The drama of this relationship adds to the plot as Jane wrestles with propriety and personal integrity. This is a little too much telling instead of showing for me but it is not overwhelming (and probably personal taste: I like subtlety).

My only other qualm is the ending. It's tied up with a glimpse of Jane's happy future, reminiscent of Austen. However, there are three sequels to this book. I feel like it will take the dramatic tension away in future installments. I look forward to seeing how Kowal handles this.

Overall, this is an easy, light, fun read. It's perfect for book clubs (quick with lots of good discussion about the purpose of period fiction, social commentary, and genre-crossing books), a beach read for those who want more than pure fluff, and for getting that friend that refuses to read "wizard books" into a different sub-genre of fantasy. Definitely interested in reading the sequels.

View all my reviews

Review - Words of Radiance by Brandon Sanderson

Words of Radiance by Brandon Sanderson
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

And breathe. (spoilers marked)

Epic. Truly epic. I hesitated to give this 5 stars simply because I want to be able to rate the later entries relatively higher if it improves from here, but it would be a disservice to give it 4. The pacing is excellent, never slacking, often intense. The characters are easily the best Sanderson has ever written, with complex, flawed motivations and goals. You could read this story just for the basic plot but where's the fun in ignoring the rich, hint-laden undercurrents? It's not for a new fantasy reader but rewards long time fans with a complex world and vivid characters.

I've rarely read a second-in-a-series book that had this much energy and individuality. Sanderson's choice to use each book as a backstory focus for one character is really working to keep the story fresh, although Shallan's story left me with as many questions as answers!

Some personal (and spoiler-marked) thoughts:
-Pleasantly surprised to find that I enjoyed Shallan's present-day storyline (view spoiler)[even without my favorite character, Jasnah (hide spoiler)].
-Adolin is also growing on me, particularly as his slightly antagonistic relationship with Kaladin evolves. Plus, he and (view spoiler)[Shallan (hide spoiler)] are a fun match.
-Super excited that (view spoiler)[Jasnah's not really dead. So tired of the dead mentor so the hero can rise trope. Loved the epilogue with her and Wit. (hide spoiler)]
-Sanderson's descriptions of Kaladin's recurring depression and his anxiety about when/if it will return. Just... spot on, especially with how it never really leaves him. Kaladin bothered me when I read Way of Kings the first time but 3 years later, I really get it.
-If you're willing to go even slightly down the rabbit hole on 17th Shard or Coppermind, this book becomes a much richer experience. (This will also improve your reading of book #1's pacing, IMO.)
-The story left me with sincere tears in places (pg 849 I'm looking at you) and made me catch my breath in several places (especially (view spoiler)[Adolin's 4-on-1 fight and Kaladin jumping into the ring (hide spoiler)]).

In short, if you like Sanderson, you'll like this one. I think it will even convert those fans who were on the fence about Way of Kings. Highly, highly recommended for epic fantasy fans.

View all my reviews

Review - The Way of Kings by Brandon Sanderson

The Way of Kings by Brandon Sanderson
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I have to admit, I was worried for the first 500 pages. This book is slow going at first. Early on, I found it difficult to really root for Kaladin (who wallowed in his own crapulance a lot) and for Dalinar (who has a crisis and withdraws from life). Fortunately, the Shallan/Jasnah storyline kept me pulling through and was, for me, the best of the three throughout.

All the main characters are vividly drawn and their personalities are intact and consistent throughout, which gets high marks in my opinion. Otherwise, how could I loathe Dalinar's inaction and Kaladin's wallowing? And let me not forget the two most dynamic characters of all, Syl and Wit(view spoiler)[/Hoid (hide spoiler)]. Having just come off reading Robin Hobb's Farseer Trilogy, I love that Wit, like Hobb's Fool, seems too knowledgeable and yet powerless. It works well in Way of Kings. All the secondary characters (and who knows how long they'll remain secondary) are brightly written as well. I enjoyed scenes with Adolin, Renarin, Danlan, Navani, Elkohar, Rock, Teft, Sigzil, and Taravangian.

I only have one small quibble with this book and it's really more of a request for future installments: Please, more of the women. Perhaps the clichest of cliches in modern fantasy is the male hero with female supporting cast. Navani, Danlan, and especially Jasnah and Shallan are very well written and deserve just as much "screen time" as the battle fighting heroes; they don't receive it in this book. The story moves well and Jasnah and Shallan's "big reveals" needed to wait to the end for plot reasons, so I understand spacing out Shallan's viewpoints, but I hope that the rest of the series will have more of these leading ladies.

There are, of course, plenty of cliffhangers by the end. (view spoiler)[What is Teft/Sigzil/Rock's full story? Who are the Ghostbloods and what do they want? What does Taravangian hope to accomplish? Will Szeth succeed in killing Dalinar or can Kaladin/Jasnah/Shallan thwart him? What is a Truthless? Why does Jasnah dislike her mother? What did Dalinar request of the Old Magic and what did it cost him? and so on. (hide spoiler)]

A review such as this can't begin to approach the complexity of this book and it is, regardless, difficult to write a complete review of the first book in a series without a series to place it in. So I'll say this:

For fantasy fans who are worried about getting sucked into yet another endless series, this one felt more deliberate to me. Sanderson has a track record of delivering on extremely challenging deadlines and The Way of Kings is clearly a meticulously thought out plot. It may be a long series, but I feel like it will be worth the wait. The story is layered and twisted, the world-building is interesting without being gratuitous, the battles are spectacular, the characters are varied and vivid and complex. I will gladly keep shelling out money and time for this series if all the other books are this well executed.

ETA: I later re-read this book when the sequel was published.  Read that review here.

Review - Murder of Crows by Anne Bishop

Murder of Crows by Anne Bishop
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Much like the first book in this series, I started by feeling a little... off about this book. It seemed too contrived, too naive-girl-falls-for-clueless-alpha-male (that's a category, right?). But. Somewhere about halfway through this book I realized that what I was actually reading was a book about culture clash. About Us versus Them and how we get there and how very, very hard it is to back away from that. Bishop's character work is subtle here... although you're rooting along the way for the main characters, you begin to realize that the Others are clearly not in the right here, although neither are the humans who are violently targeting the terra indigene or the blood prophets. One reviewer described the romance line in this book as a slow burn but I think it's a solid description of the series as well.

I still had a few qualms with this book. For instance, Bishop hasn't fully explored how the Others' inconsistent and strangling treatment of humanity, a sentient species, is directly related to the justified resentment of humanity and thereby the uprising of humans against them (although from the tone of this book, I expect this won't be long in coming). Some descriptions are too much tell instead of show (e.g. Tess seemed permanently pissed off, so the continuing descriptions of her red, coiling hair weren't really helping me get a feeling for the dynamic tension ). And it really is a little too much naive-girl-falls-for-clueless-alpha-male at the beginning, with some campy moments that were more cringe-inducing than funny for me. However, the world-building was excellent: the introduction of the Intuits, seeing other Courtyard Others, hints of a larger conflict brewing overseas. I'm still having trouble connecting emotionally with Meg but really enjoyed the parallel internal conflicts of Simon and Monty as they try to reconcile radically different ways of life and justice. I get jumpy just thinking of Monty's daughter Lizzy and the anticipation of trouble brewing there, so Bishop has clearly succeeded in getting me to invest in this world.

Ultimately, this is a in-it-for-the-long-haul style series with steady, subtle development of themes of how we treat the Other, how conflicts escalate, and the tremendous vision and courage it takes to alter the seemingly inevitable without destroying the touchstones of identity. I'm more excited to read the third installment in this series than I've been for a new Bishop book since the publication of the last Black Jewels book. Highly recommended for fantasy fans.

Review - Written in Red by Anne Bishop

Written in Red by Anne Bishop
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This is a novel which benefits from a patient reader who is willing to suspend early judgement. I had my doubts about it for a bit. The story is slow to become detailed enough for my enjoyment. There were times that I felt the internal "rules" of the Others weren't clear enough or followed consistently. For instance, early on we see the Others attack and eat 3 men who trespass, with no chance given for an explanation. Yet they tolerate Asia Crane's meddling with nothing more than snarls till she knowingly breaks a rule, at which point she is only banished. And in they meantime, the human employees come and go with no sense of terror. I feel like any sentient species should have worked up a consistent justice system, even if it is a violent one, in order to prevent complete anarchy from taking over. There must be some rule system that is not well shown.

However, as always, Bishop's characters shone through. While I wasn't a huge fan of the lead character, Meg, the secondary characters really pull you into the alternate world story that the author has built. There are many tales hinted at and left to explore in this world, which could easily surpass her Black Jewels series in complexity, if Bishop will stretch her authorial wings a bit. Sam was a particular favorite of mine, as Bishop uses him to let you get comfortable with the Others and then reminds the reader rather forcefully that he is a Wolf, not a dog. Her representation of two cultures at a crossroads of change was interesting; I was originally a little vexed with what appeared to be inconsistencies until I realized that two cultures starting to reach out to each other would be very hit-or-miss in their understanding.

Definitely recommended for fans of Bishop's previous work, who will find commonalities from earlier series amongst the newer elements of this setting. This would also make an excellent entry novel into alternate-world fantasy for a new fantasy reader, as it is not heavy on alternate vocabulary or magic rules which might be offputting to a novice reader. I am very much looking forward to the sequel, due out in about a year.

Review - The Traitor Queen by Trudi Canavan

The Traitor Queen by Trudi Canavan
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I greatly, greatly enjoyed this one. This was definitely a trilogy that got better as it went, starting at "good" and finishing at "where's the next one?!?". Canavan's work is never the most subtly deep of the fantasy I read but her society-building is second to none. This book was a great culmination of the relationships and conflicts set up in the first two books, with some nice character moments throughout. In particular, I love Canavan's willingness to explore the "no right answer" problems when societies clash, as well as questions of how much do good intentions and acts outweigh bad societies and acts. Canavan's use of good people on the bad side of things versus bad people on the good side never devolved to the strawman level and promoted the idea that people are often much more complicated than they seem.

All-in-all, a pleasantly more thought-provoking read than I expected. Recommended to general fantasy fans as well as fans of Canavan's previous work. Reading the Traitor Spy trilogy is definitely helped by reading her prior Black Magician trilogy.

View all my reviews

Review - The Rogue by Trudi Canavan

The Rogue by Trudi Canavan
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Better than its predecessor, Canavan gets and keep the plot rolling through the entire book. I liked the introduction of Lilia to the cast, as we haven't had a Novice in this mix yet. (Although it's actually nice that the majority of the protagonists in this trilogy are middle-aged.) The plot moved much more steadily and continues to not revolve around the magical abilities of the characters as a device to move forward.

The aspect I continued to have the most trouble with, however, is connecting emotionally to the characters. It's a bit like a friend telling you a distressing story about someone you've never met. You know it must be horrible for them but you only sporadically connect their emotions with yours. There's nothing flawed in the storytelling per se, it's just my preference that I feel what the characters are experiencing.

Despite that, the story is engaging and I particularly appreciate Canavan's ability to portray all styles of relationships, from mentors and friends and lovers to the more ambiguous, could/should questions that come up in real life. I also like that her characters make intelligent choices and live with them, even when they're working on flawed information. There's a lot to admire in who her characters are as people, which is a nice change from much of what I've read lately.

Recommended to Canavan's fans and general fantasy readers. Easily appropriate for teens as well, for those who are concerned with content warnings.

View all my reviews

Review - The Ambassador's Mission by Trudi Canavan

The Ambassador's Mission by Trudi Canavan
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

This was a fun, quick read, although I would have greatly benefited from re-reading the preceding trilogy and prequel. I had trouble remembering what the strengths/limits of the magic on this world are. Fortunately, Canavan's plot doesn't anchor on this point and it was easy to slip back into the Kyralian world regardless.

It felt like it took awhile for the story to get going but fortunately, I have the rest of the trilogy on hand to keep going. I'm especially impressed at Canavan's ability to differentiate individuals from their society; no character here is a stereotype. The plot itself does suffer a bit for the "telling instead of showing" problem but the characters are likeable enough to pull you through.

Recommended to Canavan's fans and those looking for a lighter fantasy read.

View all my reviews

Review - The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch

The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

The Lies of Locke Lamora is very different from other fantasy I've read in the past few years. Substitute a lot of morally questionable characters for the hero and his sidekicks and put them on a quest for money/power/revenge instead of to save the world, and you have some idea of what you're in for. Lynch is particularly skilled at making you root for the less-bad characters against the more-bad characters, an impressive feat; this could easily have been an unreadable story due to the repugnance of the characters involved.

Things I liked:
-The cussing/invective everywhere. Very atmospheric and helped with the world-building by reminding me of the unique religious elements of this society. I also enjoyed that the society/geography was loosely Italian, rather than English or French.
-A daring choice in narrative as there are no "good guys" here. No moral philosophers trying to better humanity, just people out to gain and keep their own little enclave of power.
-I have no idea if Lynch will develop it but the world-building was interesting. I would love to see more discovery of who created the Elderglass and why, as well as more concrete information about the bondsmage magic.
-While the book is typically about male protagonists, Lynch's female characters are well done. They have interests, hobbies, thoughts and inputs into the situation in Camorr. This makes me especially curious to see what he eventually does with Sabetha.

Things I disliked:
-Way too much description for my taste. Skimmed whole passages with no loss of storyline.
-Plotline isn't terribly clever. It's not stupid either and holds together well, it's just that the "big reveals" of the plot don't have much emotional impact (oh look, another character out for revenge/greed/maintaining-the-status-quo!). It's also less about foresighted planning and more about Locke Lamora barreling through and forcing events to conform to his design.
-Reminds me a bit too much of Clive Cussler's Dirk Pitt series, in that there is lots of stomach-churning violence but the two buddy-leads of the story are strangely immune from lethal blows, despite heaps of corpses provided by secondary characters.
-It needed a better map (larger scale) and a list of the gods and their realms.

Overall, something a little different for the fantasy reading crowd. If you can stomach descriptive violence and lots of morally challenged characters, this one is worth a look. This does work well as a standalone novel but I'll probably go on to read the next one of a projected 7 book series eventually.

View all my reviews