Review - Thief's Magic by Trudi Canavan (Millenium Rule #1)

Thief's Magic by Trudi Canavan

My rating: 4 of 5 stars



I wavered between 3 and 5 stars with this book, almost always at different sections. It's told from the perspective of two protagonists, Tyen and Rielle, who are on different worlds with the same magic system basis. Canavan is attempting something more epic than her previous works and with some pretty solid success. While both of the lead characters' stories were complete for a "first in a series" book, Canavan lays down some tantalizing hints of the larger mechanics and mythology of this universe.

Tyen's story, which kicks off the book, was attention grabbing but flagged for me through the middle of the book. I had to keep reminding myself that Canavan is not a "more than meets the eye" kind of writer; there are no sudden reversals or "why didn't I see that?!" moments. The story relies heavily on your sympathy with the protagonists, which was somewhat weak for me in Tyen's sections. Rielle, on the other hand, was interesting throughout (the 5 star sections were exclusively hers). I did enjoy the secondary characters in both storylines; Canavan's cast is full of individuals, not Examples of a Type. The contrast amongst the priests of Rielle's world were particularly good.

Definitely looking forward to the follow ups. Recommended for Canavan's fans and readers looking for a new, solid epic fantasy series.

Review - Valour and Vanity (Glamourist #4)

Valour and Vanity by Mary Robinette Kowal

My rating: 5 of 5 stars



Kowal's (by now characteristic) thorough research and attention to detail shines again to create a fascinating and immersive story. In particular, I loved the insights into different strata of life in this novel, the very poor, the working class, the well-off, the nuns, etc. They all felt like people, never caricatures, which takes careful work. As a fantasy fan, I also liked the furthering of glamour techniques and the Vincents' skills as a "development of magic" angle. I'm very curious to see where that goes in the final novel!

My only qualm with this book was the beginning. It's a heist novel and the end comeuppance is tight and excellent and clever, everything I could have asked for. (Kowal writes a little in the afterword about how the final action scene needed to be written and I'm awed at the flawless execution.) But the early groundwork felt a little too slow to develop, as Jane's trusting nature obscures the underlying plot. I debated whether this was my lack of insight or the way it was written and I suspect it's a little of both. Jane's point of view is written so engrossingly that it was difficult for me to step outside it and consider other angles. All-in-all, it's a characteristic of the character-based story and not a flaw; definitely an experience that makes me want to re-read to see what I get out of it a second time.

The highlight of this book, as always, were the characters of Jane & Vincent. I greatly enjoyed my time in their company, particularly as their situation strained & strengthened their relationship. Kowal deftly handles their reactions to events past and present, never glossing over the strain that these events can place on even the most loving relationships.

This is the 4th book of a projected 5 book series and is still highly recommended for fantasy fans, regency readers, and now fans of heist novels!

Review - Death by Darjeeling by Laura Childs

Death by Darjeeling by Laura Childs

My rating: 4 of 5 stars



Really excellent start to a cozy mystery series and just the mental break I needed from my recent reading list. I greatly enjoyed the world Childs describes by following amateur sleuth Theodosia through downtown Charleston and its surrounding area. She does a wonderful job evoking the class and culture of modern day tea consumption and beautifully describes Charleston. While I've never visited, I certainly want to go now!

I particularly appreciated that Childs didn't make Theodosia into a character more knowledgeable than she should be. Theo, an upper-middle class tea room owner and former marketing guru, mostly uses her social connections and bravado to push her way into finding out what has happened to the murder victim, rather than any surprisingly-applicable training or skill. Childs did a marvelous job setting up for a longer series by introducing any number of colorful secondary characters and giving the lead room to grow. My only quibbles with this book were the slightly overdone descriptions of the local scenes (just my preference; they were evocative) and the abrupt transitions, often from Theodosia's POV to a suspect's and back again, with no real purpose or physical break in the narrative.

Definitely a book for those who like their mysteries long on character and short on gruesome. Just be warned that the food & tea descriptions are likely to make you long for fattening baked goods and a perfectly brewed cup! Looking forward to continuing with this series in Gunpowder Green.

Review - The Way of Kings (Revisited) by Brandon Sanderson

The Way of Kings by Brandon Sanderson

My rating: 4 of 5 stars



This was my second read of this novel (see my first review) and occurred both before, during, and after I read its sequel, Words of Radiance. It holds up well after 3 years and, frankly, was a better read after I finished #2. Some plot and thematic elements become more apparent and reading them back to back lets one eliminate the initial bump of in-world terminology.

I found Kaladin a much more tolerable lead character this time. Since the book's initial publication, when I first read it, I've learned much more about depression and its inescapable presence. Kaladin reads as an authentic depressed character now that I've put that together. Dalinar again annoyed me a bit, although Adolin was also more interesting after reading book 2. Nonetheless, Jasnah & Shallan are still my favorite storyline and I greatly enjoyed the secondary cast of characters.

Definitely still recommended for epic fantasy fans. At only 2 books in, this world is already rich and deep enough to get more out of the first installment.

Review - The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms by N. K. Jemisin

The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms by N.K. Jemisin

My rating: 3 of 5 stars



I wavered between 3 and 4 stars for this. While it was a solid read, I probably won't pick it up again, although I will read the sequel.

Part of my issue with the book was my expectations, as usual. When your main character is thrust into a scheming, ends-justifies-the-means ruling family, I was set up to read some vicious politicking and clever court intrigue. Instead, this novel is more a story about the enslaved gods' rise to freedom via Yeine's personal beliefs. Also a good story but I kept expecting a double cross or redemption somewhere that never happened.

But. The worldbuilding was excellent. I want to know more, more, more about what happens to this world. And the not-overdone commentary on slavery, lack of gender issues, and especially Jemisin's show-not-tell story on how others expectations shape us were all thought provoking. The secondary characters were a bit two dimensional but Yeine, Nahadoth, Sieh, and Enefa were all interesting.

Worth a read through for fantasy fans looking for something a little different, if you can tolerate the odd moment of extreme violence. I'm looking forward to the next installment.

Review - Wintersmith by Terry Pratchett

Wintersmith by Terry Pratchett

My rating: 4 of 5 stars



This was my first ever Terry Pratchett book and if they're all like this, I could be spending many hours with this author in the near future.

The book never takes itself too seriously, which means the reader really can't either. But don't let that belie the solid craft and excellent story at work here. Pratchett has fun at the expense of many a trope or fantasy element and consistently underscores the point of Story: what we learn about ourselves as a result. I have an engineer's brain that likes to find and solve problems, so it's rare for me to say that there's nothing wrong with a book. It was so nice to sit back and just enjoy a story without having to say "except for this one thing...".

This may be a little dense for those not accustomed to fantasy/fairy tales/mythology but if you have even a passing familiarity with any one of those, I imagine you would find something fun here. Not an earth shattering, mind bending read but very enjoyable. I'll definitely be picking up more Discworld books in the future.

Review - Except the Queen by Jane Yolen and Midori Snyder

Except the Queen by Jane Yolen & Midori Snyder

My rating: 3 of 5 stars



I read this for my book club and hoped that the discussion would let me decide if I liked it or not. Alas, this was not to be.

There's nothing really wrong with this book and I suspect I was simply not the intended audience (not a huge follower of fae/fairy tales, so many of the plot elements left me puzzled). I just never felt particularly connected to the characters. Or the plot. Or the world.

It was an easy enough read and I enjoyed the gentle humor inherent in two people finding their way in an unfamiliar culture.

I've read books by Yolen before and enjoyed them and have several of Snyder's on my "to read" list. This book didn't made me move Snyder's work ahead or behind where it is now.

Recommended to those interested in both fairy tales and urban fantasy.